DAY 1 · HIGH-IMPACT CLAIM REVIEW
From 338 candidates to the first release-critical claims
These are the statements most likely to shape a colleague's understanding of CIDM or the iCIDM prototype.
22 QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY
5 PUBLIC_WITH_EXPLICIT_BOUNDARY
3 REVIEW_REQUIRED
Release rule: a number can be public-ready while its interpretation remains qualified. Evidence binding does not turn a structural pattern into a scientific conclusion.
| # | ID | Claim | Evidence binding | Boundary | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0336 | Corpus Boundary 2,231 is a working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution still needs status-aware curation where required. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 2 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0010 | Digital CIDM · RECOVERED 2,231 publication objects and 8,061 source-derived typed links. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 3 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0025 | 2,231 curated publications (1995–2026 project corpus), ready to connect authors, pathogens, technologies, themes, questions and evidence. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 4 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0218 | Claim Passport ICIDM-CLAIM-003 The 2,231-publication corpus can be treated as a recoverable institutional memory population from which methods, evidence, relationships and questions may be reconstructed. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 5 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0004 | What did CIDM publish? Start from the 2,231-paper institutional memory. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 6 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0009 | CIDM Navigator · RECOVERED 3,299 source-derived typed routes with explicit evidence boundaries. | cidm_navigator.html | Typed routes derived from source classifications; route existence does not establish causality, scientific importance, or institutional capability. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 7 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0027 | Next data step: import the actual 2,231-publication and 460-reference records into the City object graph rather than manufacturing placeholder paper records. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 8 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0030 | The CIDM publication corpus is now represented as 2,231 real publication objects with stable City IDs and source-derived links to themes, pathogens, technologies, journals and investigator-search sources. This is no longer a mock population. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 9 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0042 | Digital CIDM is a reality-linked reference implementation. The 2,231 records are source-derived; institutional affiliation verification remains an explicit curation boundary. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 10 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0052 | iSydney Digital CIDM 2,231 Explorer CIDM Navigator 460 Reference Gateway Museum | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 11 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0073 | iSydney Digital CIDM Explorer Navigator All Journeys Signature Journeys Capability Review 460 Gateway | reference_gateway.html | Reference architecture/target population is retained; canonical 460-record recovery/matching remains a governed data boundary. | PUBLIC_WITH_EXPLICIT_BOUNDARY |
| 12 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0048 | All years 2026 2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000 1999 1998 1997 1996 1995 All themes Clinical microbiology / infectious diseases COVID-19 / respiratory viruses Diagnostics / laboratory methods Clinical infectious diseases Medical mycology Antimicrobial resistance Public health / epidemiology Genomics / bioinformatics Me... | cidm_publication_explorer.html | Page-visible working claim; canonical source binding should be strengthened before external publication. | REVIEW_REQUIRED |
| 13 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0008 | 2,231 Publication Explorer · RECOVERED Search title, authors, PMID, DOI, year, theme, pathogen and technology. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 14 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0029 | iSydney Digital CIDM 2,231 Explorer Knowledge District CIDM Passport Citizens Museum | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 15 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0032 | 2,231 real publication objects | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 16 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0037 | Browse all 2,231 publications | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 17 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0045 | 2,231 real publication citizens | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 18 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0049 | 2,231 publications shown. Classification fields are source-derived from the workbook; affiliation verification remains pending. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 19 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0053 | The 2,231 publication citizens are no longer only searchable. They now have deterministic, typed routes derived from the master workbook's bibliographic and CKID classification fields. | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 20 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0055 | 3,299 typed Navigator routes | cidm_navigator.html | Typed routes derived from source classifications; route existence does not establish causality, scientific importance, or institutional capability. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 21 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0062 | iSydney Digital CIDM Explorer Navigator Knowledge Journeys 460 Gateway | reference_gateway.html | Reference architecture/target population is retained; canonical 460-record recovery/matching remains a governed data boundary. | PUBLIC_WITH_EXPLICIT_BOUNDARY |
| 22 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0075 | These are the strongest corpus-level pathways selected from the 178 observed journeys using only transparent structural criteria: publication volume, temporal span, journal diversity and recent activity. | cidm_knowledge_journeys.html | Observed repeated corpus pathways; not automatically validated capabilities. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 23 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0253 | 2,231 publications | CIDM-30Y-master-v2.0 source-derived working corpus | cidm_publication_explorer.html | digital_cidm.html | Working 1995–2026 publication portrait; institutional attribution/affiliation remains a curation boundary where applicable. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 24 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0038 | Each retained 1995–2026 publication receives a stable Digital CIDM ID from CPD-0001 to CPD-2231. | digital_cidm.html | Page-visible working claim; canonical source binding should be strengthened before external publication. | REVIEW_REQUIRED |
| 25 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0046 | Search the canonical 1995–2026 slice of the CIDM PubMed master. Click any publication to inspect its City Passport and source-derived connections. | cidm_publication_explorer.html | Page-visible working claim; canonical source binding should be strengthened before external publication. | REVIEW_REQUIRED |
| 26 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0011 | 460 Reference Gateway · RECOVERED ARCHITECTURE Reference architecture restored; canonical reference population remains a controlled recovery boundary. | reference_gateway.html | Reference architecture/target population is retained; canonical 460-record recovery/matching remains a governed data boundary. | PUBLIC_WITH_EXPLICIT_BOUNDARY |
| 27 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0013 | 178 Knowledge Journeys Repeated pathogen×technology and theme×technology roads across time; observational, not automatically validated. | cidm_knowledge_journeys.html | Observed repeated corpus pathways; not automatically validated capabilities. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 28 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0026 | 460 active reference passports , designed for provenance, status, reuse and relationship navigation. | reference_gateway.html | Reference architecture/target population is retained; canonical 460-record recovery/matching remains a governed data boundary. | PUBLIC_WITH_EXPLICIT_BOUNDARY |
| 29 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0033 | 8,061 source-derived typed links | digital_cidm.html | Source-derived typed links in the current Digital CIDM representation; structural links are not validated scientific claims. | QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY |
| 30 | ICIDM-CLAIM-0059 | When the canonical 460-reference population is recovered, add Paper → Active Reference → Evidence / Question routes without changing this architecture. | reference_gateway.html | Reference architecture/target population is retained; canonical 460-record recovery/matching remains a governed data boundary. | PUBLIC_WITH_EXPLICIT_BOUNDARY |
Next promotion step
Claims marked QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_READY can remain visible with their boundary. REVIEW_REQUIRED claims should not be promoted into headline institutional conclusions until domain/HI review. The 460-reference claim stays public only with its explicit recovery boundary.