← Consciousness Observatory · Living Work Routing · Release / QA

C508 Correction & Version State

This surface shows what happens after a challenge. It distinguishes a correction mechanism from an actually accepted correction.

OBSERVE / CHALLENGE → TRACE → SOURCE / EVIDENCE RETURN → REVIEW / DECISION → VERSION EVENT (only if accepted) → PROPAGATE → QA → REOPENABLE

1populated object-specific OPEN correction record

0accepted corrections claimed by this generated view

0canonical propagation events claimed by this generated view

No silent overwrite. Submission or OPEN status does not alter the canonical scientific value. Rejected challenges remain auditable; UNKNOWN may remain; an accepted correction must preserve the prior version.

Populated record currently exposed

CPID-218 · CORR-CPID-218-REVIEW-001

Status: OPEN. Trigger: iReview pilot. Current state: RETRACTED_PRIMARY_SOURCE_RETAINED_FOR_PROVENANCE. No proposed replacement state is recorded, so no correction or propagation is claimed.

Propagation contract

Only after an accepted, source-traceable decision may mechanical propagation update affected generated surfaces: canonical object/cell record, Passport view, population summaries, provenance/review view, Unknown state where relevant, version log, and release QA. Scientific adjudication itself is not automated.

External criticism

Author, reader, Kuhn/LoC, expert, or independent-review feedback can trigger this loop. Such feedback is observer/representation evidence; it is not automatically empirical or ontological truth.

Machine-readable view: C508_Living_Correction_Version_State_v1_0.json